These attacks on Dr. Yahav are completely inappropriate and baseless. He is an excellent clinician who has developed a product that is useful to many who use calcium sulfate (CS) and hydroxyapatite (HA) in their practices. These type of nonsensical comments about calcium sulfate (CS) always come up here whenever anyone mentions the material. If you don't like the product, and want to use other grafting materials, that's fine, don't buy it. Everyone can use what they want. But don't besmirch the name of a highly qualified and honest professional for ridiculous reasons. Personally, I use many types of grafting materials, and ocassionally will use bond apatite for specific cases, because I have seen the benefits of CS. Honestly, all of these materials work, including allograft and xenograft. And in the long run all the costs are pretty much the same, because of certain variables. It really all depends on the case.
The fact of the matter is that calcium sulfate (CS) and hydroxyapatite (HA), the two ingredients in bond apatite, have been used successfully in grafting procedures for decades already (actually I think CS has a century of use), in many medical disciplines, including spinal surgery, orthopedics and dentistry. There are hundreds of studies backing up the use of these materials, which anyone can easily find at Pubmed. There is nothing innovative or new about these types of grafting materials. They are clinically proven. You may not want or use CS or HA for grafting, but to question the efficacy of CS for grafting procedures shows complete ignorance.
What Dr. Yahav has done with Bond Apatite is simply provide a simpler, and faster mechanism for delivering CS and HA for dental procedures. If you use these materials, you will understand the benefits of bond apatite. If you haven't then you probably won't understand the benefits. But, I suggest you try them, and you will see that CS is an excellent material to use in certain cases.
As for the cost, if you have the time, and think you can buy CS and HA yourself cheaper, and mix it up appropriately yourself, then by all means do so. Others who have tried just this method, and who value their time, will appreciate a better delivery mechanism and pay for it. By the way, you can also buy CS, as Dentogen. It's cheaper than Bond Apatite, but it is not mixed up with HA, and doesn't have a delivery mechanism. I've bought both, and don't recommend one of the other. It depends on what you are doing. Some people like to mix CS with allograft, in which case, Dentogen is probably the better solution. Others want to use only synthetic materials, in which case, you will want to consider Bond Apatite.
Of course, you can also buy plaster of paris (CS) at Walmart, mix it up, and apply it for your patients. You will certainly save alot of money doing this, but you also probably lose your dental license. Presumably, those who recommend this way of doing things, are also buying a wrench at Home Depot to extract teeth. I think these types of arguments are silly, of course.
One interesting thing about CS, by the way, is that because CS functions like a membrane, you may not need a membrane when using CS or bond apatite for certain cases, which factors into the cost equation.