Rocking Implant: how can I determine what is loose?
One month following insertion of a crown on an implant in #3 site [maxillary right first molar; 16] there is apparent buccolingula movement of the crown or crown/abutment/implant. The patient can even wiggle the crown with her tongue. I cannot determine exactly what is loose. The radiographs show a well integrated implant with no discernible pathosis.  How can I determine if just the crown is loose or if the abutment is loose or if the crown/abutment/implant is loose?
23 Comments on Rocking Implant: how can I determine what is loose?
New comments are currently closed for this post.
CRS
1/7/2013
It would be helpful to post a radiograph, if the implant was integrated one month ago it will not be mobile that quickly, the abutment screw could be fractured or if the crown is screwed in it could be loose. A cemented crown would fall out if it were loose. Usually the abutment screw is the culprit on such a short timeframe. What kind of implant? And a radiograph would be very helpful in solving this. Think you have to take it in steps, remove the crown then the abutment and you should be able to tell. I doubt it is the implant, the patient would probably have some pain or symptoms. Good luck.
Peter Fairbairn
1/8/2013
The key to Dental Implantology is deling with problems ( albeit rare ) sadly.
Hopefully just a loose screw with a hex type abutment or a indexed taper that has not been located correctly.
Generally youi can feel when it is merely the screw as it has a "metallic " rattle when you move it hwereas if the implant is the issue when you move it it a more "solid" movement which can be associated with pain.
The only way is to remove the crown ( hopefully you used a retrievable cement ) and torque it down.
Peter
Edward Dergosits
1/13/2013
Even when a "retrievable" cement has been used it is very often impossible to remove a crown from an abutment with a loose screw without breaking the screw. If the crown cannot be removed with gentle distraction than it would be wise to make an access on the occlusal of the crown to gain access to the abutment screw. I always replace an abutment screw that has come loose. Re torquing the same one that has come loose is asking for problems in my experience. The most common cause of screw loosing is when tissue was trapped in the I/A interface at the time of placement. Initial torque values can be achieved but as the soft trapped tissue liquifies the abutment begins to rock and the screw comes loose. Implants with indexed and tapered conical connections are much better suited for single tooth replacements for many reasons. Ed
Jay West
1/8/2013
I was lucky once and made an endo access hole in the crown, found the abutment and the screw and retighten the abutment down and refilled the access.
Charles Schlesinger, DDS,
1/8/2013
Can you pull up on the crown and make it move occlusally? If so, put an explorer at the crown abutment margin and move the crown. If you feel movement on the explorer it is the abutment, if you feel the margin open up, it is the crown.
Most likey it is the abutment screw. I agree with Jay West- if you can make an access through the crown, then you can retorque the screw and place composite in teh access. Good luck!
Dr. Trevor
1/8/2013
Replace the screw.
Jay presented a very good option. My concern is that while the abutment was loose, the screw may bend slightly, or a few threads will become damaged. Re-torquing a damaged screw will result in a repeat.
Did you block out the screw access hole before cementing the crown? All responses have presumed that the screw is easy to access. If not, it is a more complicated issue than we have addressed.
Edward Dergosits
1/13/2013
Always replace the screw. Metal deformation is real. Ed
JC
1/8/2013
possible a controversial post and i maybe need to duck when i say this one.
But surely this is another example of when it is better to try and have screw retained restorations as opposed to cement?
As i said, DUCK!
Ben
1/8/2013
Stand proud on screw retained restorations! What better way to disinfect all the supra-fixture components, and access the fixture, than by removing the restoration. Remove one once, see all the biofilm and other debris adhering to the removable components, and you'll never want to cement another restoration again!
Ron Barbanell
1/8/2013
No need to duck.
I have been placing implants 35 years.
I have placed more than most.
95% screw retained.
When you have maintained your implants and restotrations for decades, retrievability is a blessing.
sampson
1/8/2013
No need to duck or shy away from this. More and more people are advocating a return to screw-retained restorations due to problems with cement and peri-implantitis. My opinion is that if the angulation of the implant will allow it, retain it with a screw.
Dr. Dan Even
1/8/2013
Hi . I suggest to proceed with these steps :
1.Take an X-ray ( check to any space between fixture and abutment )
2.Remove//unscrew crown ( if it's a screwed crown )
3.Check the abutment screw and the fixture stability .
4.resolve the problem.
Good luck !!
Dan
Michael W. Johnson DDS, M
1/8/2013
If the xray looks good and there's no pain it's probably a loose screw. A loose implant tends to be symptomatic and has radiographic and clinical evidence of pathology. Remove crown, tighten screw and figure out why the screw loosened so soon. Did you torque the screw to the proper torque with a torque driver? Isn't implant dentistry fun!!!
Dr. Omar Olalde
1/8/2013
Much probably is the screw and obviously the abutment, so remove the crown.
Good news, much probably the implant is ok.
Bad news, I think you have to cut the crown to remove it, because is very difficult to remove the crown with a loosen abutment, you can brake the screw, even with a temporary cement.
And if the patient accept, as some Doctors wrote, do an acces on the oclusal surface, only if it is a metal-porcelain crown.
Good luck.
Vipul G Shukla
1/8/2013
This one appears to be easy to solve! If the crown (cemented or screwed-in?) went in four weeks ago, then I guess the abutment screw is loose due to loading.
Or rarely, the prosthetic screw needs tightening, which if its a cemented crown, you may want to try an access hole through the middle as Dr West suggested above. When re-tightening screws down on a well-integrated implant, try tightening once to recommended torque, then open again, then tighten back to full torque a second time using the correct torque wrench. Learned it from a plumber!
Neil Nepal
1/8/2013
1. Try an abutment screw access hole through the crown. It may be difficult as it's a canine, to predict where you are going.
2. You may have to cut the crown and remove it.
3. Always ensure that the torque prescribed by manufacturer is achieved during abutment tightening.
4. We all know that screw retained is superior to cement retained. The only thing may be the cost and the available lab with such expertise. And occasionally, for some systems, it may not be possible.
5. Labs can easily make an access hole in the crown during the fabrication process itself. It will help in accessing in case of failure.
Mahendra Bagur
1/9/2013
Key is not to panic..!
most of the time it is the abutment screw....
if it is screw retained- -sure you can access as an endo case..
if it is cement reatined- going to be little tricky...use two wooden wedges....most of the time the crown falls out [hope u used ZOE based cement]...
all the best
Edward Dergosits
1/13/2013
Why ZOE based? There are plenty of weak resin based temporary cements that provide even less retention.
steve m
1/9/2013
Take the crown off and see.
Keith
1/9/2013
Hopefully you still have the models. If so, you can place an implant guide pin and get a more accurate idea where the access hole is. This is assuming you didn't use a solid abutment.
Hossam Barghash
1/11/2013
first hold the crown and press it down and check mobility ,if it become fixed then it is loos abutment screw ( most common especially because some doctors they do not tightening the screw to maximum recommend torque ) or loos crown cement. second raise the crown up and see if the margin of crown move separate then it is cement , or abutment and screw move as one part and you may reach to see the fixture implant junction depending in it,s position. to fix loose screw go through an access cavity with copious irrigation do right torquing, put temporary filling and most important is to check the occlusion( another main cause of loosing screw) recheck the patient after few days if every thing is ok tightening the abutment screw again and do composite covering
Edward Dergosits
1/13/2013
I agree with most of what you advise Hossam. Proper insertion torque is important. When I place an abutment I torque the screw to the recommended insertion torque and then re torque the screw a few minutes later before cementing the crown. Almost always the screw advances further. Metal deformation of the screw may be a factor. I personally believe that minute amounts of soft tissue being trapped in the I/A interface can enable initial recommended torque values to be achieved but as the trapped tissue dissolves the abutment becomes loose. Implants with indexed conical connections reduce this possible problem. I personally will never again place an implant for a single tooth that does not have an indexed platform switched internal connection.
K. F. Chow BDS., FDSRCS
1/14/2013
What usually happens for a large single crown fixed to a fixture by a single screw is that it got unscrewed during function. This will not happen in the case of two implants splinted together by a bridge. If this is a screw retained crown, just expose the screw and replace the screw. Since it is probably a cemented crown here, use your high speed to remove the porcelain mesially and distally. This will enable you to unscrew the whole crown together with the screw. Then screw in a new abutment with a new screw and put on a new crown. Screw retained or cemented have their pros and cons. Screw retained will have a microgap which will be colonised with microbes, a possible cause of peri-implantitis. Cementation is a problem like here where you have to remove the crown. I still go with cemented because screw loosening happens usually only with single crowns. Work out a protocol where all excess cement is removed in order to pre-empt peri-implantitis, and it will be a much better option than screw retained crowns and bridges. Cementation eliminates the microgaps, which is also a cause of peri-implantitis. Take your pick.